My Daughter Scored 15% on Her State Math Test. A Year Later, She Scored 89%

In 5th grade, my daughter took the state's end-of-grade math test. It was timed, and she had the same amount of time as every other student taking it.

She scored 15%.

Because we were homeschooling, that number didn't only land on her. It landed on me, too. The state flagged our homeschool for inadequate home education and gave us one more retest. If that didn't go well, truancy came into it.

The following year, she took the 6th grade test. It was a harder test, and it was timed too, but this time she had extended time.

She scored 89%.

Same child, same math. The measure changed, not the child.

Yes, a year passed between those two tests, and she learned math that year. Of course she did. But a year of learning doesn't take a child from 15% to 89% on a harder test. Something else was going on, and it had very little to do with whether she understood the math.

That first test was measuring two things at once. It measured math, and it measured how fast she could do math. Then it blended them together and handed us a single number. And the number said she was failing.

It didn't say, "She knows more than this and needs more time to show it." Tests don't come with that footnote.

My daughter only saw that 15% once. A kid in a classroom hears some version of it over and over: bad at math, slow, lazy. After enough of that, she starts to believe it. She decides she's broken, so she stops trying, and eventually she shuts down.

I'm not guessing about that. I've watched the same pattern play out with the public school kids I tutor, one kid after another.

I'm not going to tell you test scores mean nothing. That 15% told us something real. My daughter was struggling with math, and later we would learn why. But the number couldn't tell us what she was capable of.

Nobody had given her the time to show it.

A child can be struggling and smart at the same time.

So let me ask you about your number. Maybe it's a test score or a reading level. Maybe it's a report card that says "below grade level," or an evaluation that lists everything your kid can't do yet. Whatever it is, ask one question about it: is it measuring what you think it's measuring?

Tell me what you're looking at.

Angela Marie D'Antonio

Want the next one?
I write once a week about neurodiversity, education, work, and the rules we rarely question.

Read the newsletter →

Next
Next

My Daughter Struggled With Math. I Hadn't Thought About the Paper.